In a previous post, we discussed prospects for studying scheming using natural examples. In this post, we'll describe a more detailed proposal for iteratively constructing scheming models, techniques for detecting scheming, and techniques for preventing scheming. We'll call this strategy Iterated Development and Study of Schemers (IDSS). We'll be using concepts from that prior post, like the idea of trying to make schemers which are easier to catch.

Two key difficulties with using natural examples of scheming are that it is hard to catch (and re-catch) schemers and that it's hard to (cheaply) get a large number of diverse examples of scheming to experiment on. One approach for partially resolving these issues is to experiment on weak schemers which are easier to catch and cheaper to experiment on. However, these weak schemers might not be analogous to the powerful schemers which are actually dangerous, and these weak AIs [...]