This true crime podcast dives into the harrowing and intricate story of Franklin Floyd, a serial criminal who kidnapped a four-year-old girl named Suzanne. He raised her under a fake identity as Sharon Marshall, later marrying her under another false name, Tonya Hughes, before ultimately murdering her. The narrative unfolds through three interconnected stories: Sharon's seemingly perfect high school life, Tonya's abusive marriage and tragic death, and Sandra Brandenburg's struggles with motherhood and sex work. As the podcast progresses, it uncovers their surprising ties to Floyd. The investigation, which involved the FBI, various police departments, and even an insurance company, showcases the extensive efforts needed to untangle Floyd's web of deceit and violence. It culminates in Floyd's conviction, providing a tragic resolution for Suzanne, Sharon, and Tonya.