This podcast episode explores the mysterious deaths of John and Joyce Sheridan and the questions surrounding the initial investigation. The episode discusses the initial autopsy findings, the discovery of contradicting evidence by a second medical examiner, the missing third knife from the crime scene, the inconsistencies in the investigation, and the involvement of independent investigators. The episode also highlights the aftermath of the case, including a whistleblower lawsuit, the release of an affidavit by the second medical examiner, and the potential connection to another murder-for-hire case. Despite the efforts of the Sheridan brothers to advocate for a reinvestigation, the case remains unresolved, leaving room for further investigation with limited evidence remaining.