How can a person who’s clearly lucid still be deemed incapable of making their own medical decisions? The answer lies in the misunderstood yet critical distinction between competence and decision-making capacity. While these terms are often used interchangeably in clinical settings, they carry vastly different meanings in law and medicine—differences that can determine whether a patient is treated, restrained, or left alone. In this episode, we explore how doctors can (and should) assess capacity, the legal boundaries of competence, and how not to get destroyed on the witness stand. Finally, we unpack a story involving a dog, a scrotum, and a tour of Colorado’s emergency departments.

Guest Bio: Rich Orman began his legal career as a public defender before moving into private practice. He soon joined the district attorney’s office, where he spent most of his career and ultimately rose to the position of deputy district attorney. Over three decades in the courtroom, he tried some of the most complex and high-profile cases in the state. After retiring from law, Rich turned to filmmaking. He is the writer and director of the critically acclaimed Boundary Layer.

💡 Check out our Free Resources specifically designed to address pain points in medical practice💡

We Discuss:

What Competence Actually Means in Legal Terms
Defining Medical Decision-Making Capacity
Real-Life Dilemmas in Emergency Medicine
The Right Terminology in Documentation
What Physicians Get Wrong in Court
How to Testify Like a Pro
How to Handle Yes/No Cross-Examinations
One Legal Nugget You Should Never Forget

Mentioned in this episode:

The Out-On-Time Course

Built for emergency clinicians who are tired of chart debt and getting derailed by interruptions and overwhelm. Learn practical, real-time documentation and shift-efficiency strategies to finish your shift and actually leave on time.

Learn More About The Out-On-Time Course

Decision Making Capacity Free Template

Need to document decision-making capacity quickly and accurately? I created this free resource so you don’t have to waste time looking up the elements each time. It’s an example of how it can be done—use it as a guide and make it your own.

Free Resources Link

Never Lame. Never Spammy. Always Fresh.

If you’d like a few minutes of career-elevating curated kickassery delivered to your inbox, sign up for our newsletter.

Do You Know the Difference Between Competence and Capacity?

Stimulus - Learn Tools to Crush It in Your Medical Career