The Past and Future of Societal Collapse: Why Civilizations Fall and What We Can Learn From It with Luke Kemp

In this episode of The Great Simplification, host Nate Hagens interviews Luke Kemp, an existential risk and collapse researcher, about his new book, "Goliath's Curse: The History and Future of Societal Collapse." Kemp introduces the concept of "Goliaths" as dominance hierarchies that inevitably collapse due to their inherent structure of inequality and extraction. The discussion explores the initial conditions that create Goliaths, the role of lootable resources, monopolizable weapons, and caged land, as well as psychological factors like status competition and the dark triad. Kemp argues that the entire global system can be seen as a global Goliath heading towards self-termination, a "Silicon Goliath" controlled by mass surveillance, or a potential for democratic reform. The conversation covers historical examples of societal collapses, their positive and negative outcomes, and actions that individuals can take to shift away from the Goliath dynamic.

Outlines

Sign in to continue reading, translating and more.

Continue

The Great Simplification with Nate Hagens

Introduction to Societal Collapse and Luke Kemp's "Goliath's Curse"

Defining "Goliath" and its Distinction from "Civilization"

Examples of Societies Without Dominance Hierarchies and Key Checkpoints of Civilization

The Global Goliath and the Initial Conditions for Goliath Formation: Lootable Surplus

Supernormal Stimuli, Status, and the Ingredients of a Goliath: Monopolizable Weapons and Caged Land

Status Competition, the Dark Triad, and Leveling Mechanisms in Egalitarian Societies

Psychopathy, Power Dynamics, and the Darker Angels of Our Nature

The Authoritarian Impulse, Inequality, and the Fungibility of Power

The Myth of Civilization as an Antidote to Violence and the Hobbesian Narrative

The Reality of Prehistoric Societies: Cooperation, Fluid Civilizations, and Genetic Diversity

Violence in Prehistoric Societies and the Emergence of Warfare

The Advantages of Goliaths: Babies, Bombs, Bacteria, and Barbarism

Conspicuous Consumption, Wasteful Use of Energy, and the Drivers of Collapse

Diminishing Returns on Extraction, Oligarchy, and the Inability to Respond to Crises

The Importance of an Informed Population and Defining Societal Collapse

Historical Examples of Collapse and the Question of Whether We Are in Collapse Now

The Bright Sides of Historical Collapses and What Roman Leaders Could Have Done Differently

The Fates of Goliath: Self-Termination, Silicon Goliath, and Slaying Goliath

Corporations, Goliath Traps, and the Need for Democratic Global Institutions

Actions and Policies to Shift Away from the Goliath Dynamic: Leveling Power and Making Resources Less Lootable

Climate Refugees, the Authoritarian Impulse, and the Importance of Calling Out Destructive Behavior

Energy Security vs. Climate Mitigation, Values, and the Potential for a More Hopeful Future

The Past and Future of Societal Collapse: Why Civilizations Fall and What We Can Learn From It with Luke Kemp

The Great Simplification with Nate Hagens

00:00Introduction to Societal Collapse and Luke Kemp's "Goliath's Curse"

Introduction to Societal Collapse and Luke Kemp's "Goliath's Curse"

02:43Defining "Goliath" and its Distinction from "Civilization"

Defining "Goliath" and its Distinction from "Civilization"

06:42Examples of Societies Without Dominance Hierarchies and Key Checkpoints of Civilization

Examples of Societies Without Dominance Hierarchies and Key Checkpoints of Civilization

11:11The Global Goliath and the Initial Conditions for Goliath Formation: Lootable Surplus

The Global Goliath and the Initial Conditions for Goliath Formation: Lootable Surplus

17:21Supernormal Stimuli, Status, and the Ingredients of a Goliath: Monopolizable Weapons and Caged Land

Supernormal Stimuli, Status, and the Ingredients of a Goliath: Monopolizable Weapons and Caged Land

23:08Status Competition, the Dark Triad, and Leveling Mechanisms in Egalitarian Societies

Status Competition, the Dark Triad, and Leveling Mechanisms in Egalitarian Societies

29:16Psychopathy, Power Dynamics, and the Darker Angels of Our Nature

Psychopathy, Power Dynamics, and the Darker Angels of Our Nature

35:31The Authoritarian Impulse, Inequality, and the Fungibility of Power

The Authoritarian Impulse, Inequality, and the Fungibility of Power

40:07The Myth of Civilization as an Antidote to Violence and the Hobbesian Narrative

The Myth of Civilization as an Antidote to Violence and the Hobbesian Narrative

44:46The Reality of Prehistoric Societies: Cooperation, Fluid Civilizations, and Genetic Diversity

The Reality of Prehistoric Societies: Cooperation, Fluid Civilizations, and Genetic Diversity

50:07Violence in Prehistoric Societies and the Emergence of Warfare

Violence in Prehistoric Societies and the Emergence of Warfare

57:38The Advantages of Goliaths: Babies, Bombs, Bacteria, and Barbarism

The Advantages of Goliaths: Babies, Bombs, Bacteria, and Barbarism

1:04:06Conspicuous Consumption, Wasteful Use of Energy, and the Drivers of Collapse

Conspicuous Consumption, Wasteful Use of Energy, and the Drivers of Collapse

1:10:52Diminishing Returns on Extraction, Oligarchy, and the Inability to Respond to Crises

Diminishing Returns on Extraction, Oligarchy, and the Inability to Respond to Crises

1:17:41The Importance of an Informed Population and Defining Societal Collapse

The Importance of an Informed Population and Defining Societal Collapse

1:22:21Historical Examples of Collapse and the Question of Whether We Are in Collapse Now

Historical Examples of Collapse and the Question of Whether We Are in Collapse Now

1:27:27The Bright Sides of Historical Collapses and What Roman Leaders Could Have Done Differently

The Bright Sides of Historical Collapses and What Roman Leaders Could Have Done Differently

1:34:47The Fates of Goliath: Self-Termination, Silicon Goliath, and Slaying Goliath

The Fates of Goliath: Self-Termination, Silicon Goliath, and Slaying Goliath

1:41:30Corporations, Goliath Traps, and the Need for Democratic Global Institutions

Corporations, Goliath Traps, and the Need for Democratic Global Institutions

1:47:30Actions and Policies to Shift Away from the Goliath Dynamic: Leveling Power and Making Resources Less Lootable

Actions and Policies to Shift Away from the Goliath Dynamic: Leveling Power and Making Resources Less Lootable

1:55:17Climate Refugees, the Authoritarian Impulse, and the Importance of Calling Out Destructive Behavior

Climate Refugees, the Authoritarian Impulse, and the Importance of Calling Out Destructive Behavior

2:03:04Energy Security vs. Climate Mitigation, Values, and the Potential for a More Hopeful Future

Energy Security vs. Climate Mitigation, Values, and the Potential for a More Hopeful Future