Chuck Todd reflects on the aftermath of Charlie Kirk’s assassination and what it reveals about America’s dangerously fractured politics. He explores how social media algorithms, outrage media, and polarized incentive structures are fueling political violence, with 150 politically motivated attacks already in 2025. From the dangers of cancel culture to the unwillingness of both parties to police their own extremes, Chuck argues that disagreements must stop being treated as existential threats if democracy is to function. He also considers the role of leaders like Spencer Cox, the failures of Biden and Trump to unify, and why regulating big tech and breaking out of ideological silos may be the clearest path back to a healthier, more honest political discourse.

Finally, on “This week in history” Chuck remembers Washington’s farewell address and why it perfectly meets the current moment in U.S. politics, answer questions in the “Ask Chuck” segment and gives his week 3 college football roundup.

Got injured in an accident? You could be one click away from a claim worth millions. Just visit https://www.forthepeople.com/TODDCAST to start your claim now with Morgan & Morgan without leaving your couch. Remember, it's free unless you win!

Timeline:

(Timestamps may vary based on advertisements)

00:00 Introduction

0015: It’s been a tough past five days since Kirk assassination

01:00 The system is rigged for division and against unity

05:45 There are ways to mitigate the risk of political violence, but it takes will

06:45 We’re most unified when there’s an external, existential threat

07:45 Threats from the inside only divide us

08:15 America has experienced 150 politically motivated attacks in 2025

09:30 College should be about exposure to new ideas, both good and bad

10:45 Social media playing a huge role in every political assassination attempt

12:00 Each side is convinced that violence is only coming from the other side

13:30 Politics is supposed to be about meeting somewhere in the middle

14:45 People on the left should now have a better sense of cancel culture

17:00 Policy disagreements can’t be seen as existential threats

18:00 Online discourse is so much more toxic than in-person

19:30 Social media platforms are the problem with their rage drive algorithms

21:00 Trump views this as a political moment to exploit

21:45 Trump doesn’t view that he’s been a contributor to this political climate

22:45 Politics of division has been good politics for Trump, bad for country

24:00 Incentive structures are what matter most for a healthy politics

26:00 Both parties aren’t comfortable policing their own side

27:30 Neither side is incentivized to do the right thing

28:45 On the right, the agitators are in charge

30:15 Spencer Cox might be exactly the type of leader America needs

30:45 Biden didn’t bring the country together, legislated for his base

32:30 Our political discourse radicalized the gunman

34:00 The biggest, most obvious fix is regulating big tech

35:30 We need a media that accommodates multiple ideologies

38:30 Our information silos create a lack of shared reality

40:45 Outrage media creates a loyal audience but isn’t always honest

42:45 Trying to make the ToddCast a truthful, neutral arbiter

44:00 Chuck's thoughts on interview with Frank Lavin

45:15 This week in history - George Washington's farewell address

45:45 Washington warned against political parties and factionalism

47:00 Washington preached unity above all else

49:30 Washington warned against dominating factions/partisanship

51:00 He argued to follow the Constitution and fiscal responsibility

52:00 He preached morality

53:30 He argued for peace and alliances

55:30 Ask Chuck

55:45 Thoughts on a James Talarico/Jeff Jackson ticket in 2028?

1:03:30 How can media interviewers produce better interviews?

1:08:00 How does Arkansas have such an outsized role in national politics?

1:11:00 College football needs to collectively negotiate their TV contracts

1:13:00 Week 3 college football roundup

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

Chuck’s Commentary - A Deeply Fractured & Dangerous Moment For America + Why George Washington’s Farewell Address Resonates Today

The Chuck ToddCast