Outlive: The Science & Art of Longevity by Peter Attia (with Bill Gifford[1]) gives Attia's prescription on how to live longer and stay healthy into old age. In this post, I critically review some of the book's scientific claims that stood out to me.

This is not a comprehensive review. I didn't review assertions that I was pretty sure were true (ex: VO2 max improves longevity), or that were hard for me to evaluate (ex: the mechanics of how LDL cholesterol functions in the body), or that I didn't care about (ex: sleep deprivation impairs one's ability to identify facial expressions).

First, some general notes:

I have no expertise on any of the subjects in this post. I evaluated claims by doing shallow readings of relevant scientific literature, especially meta-analyses.
There is a spectrum between two ways of being wrong: "pop science book pushes [...]

---

Outline:

(02:19) Disease

(02:22) People with metabolically healthy obesity do not have elevated mortality risk

(07:39) Amyloid beta is implicated in Alzheimers disease

(09:20) HDL cholesterol on its own doesnt prevent heart disease

(10:12) Exercise

(10:52) VO2max is the best predictor of longevity

(15:21) You should train VO2max by doing HIIT at the maximum sustainable pace

(20:26) You should do 3+ hours/week of zone 2 training and one or two sessions/week of HIIT

(23:34) Stability is as important as cardiovascular fitness and strength

(30:23) Nutrition

(30:26) Rhesus monkey studies suggest that calorie restriction improves longevity but only if you eat a fairly unhealthy diet

(38:09) The data are unclear on whether reducing saturated fat intake is beneficial

(45:59) People should take omega-3 supplements

(48:33) Sleep

(48:55) Every animal sleeps

(51:12) We need to sleep 7.5 to 8.5 hours a night

(52:24) Basketball players who were told to sleep for 10 hours a night had better shooting accuracy

(53:07) Lack of sleep increases obesity and diabetes risk

(54:27) A study using Mendelian randomization found that sleeping 6 hours a night increased risk of a heart attack

(57:03) Lack of sleep causes Alzheimers disease

(58:10) Bonus

(58:13) Dunning-Kruger effect

The original text contained 90 footnotes which were omitted from this narration.

---

First published:
July 4th, 2025

Source:
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/QqTiCz2Xz96MuEFsF/outlive-a-critical-review

---

Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.

---

Images from the article:

Graph showing VO2max changes over intervention weeks for ET, HIT, SIT training methods.

Bar graph comparing metabolic health markers across normal weight, overweight, and obesity groups.

The graph displays various metabolic indicators like NAFLD, visceral obesity, fat mass, insulin resistance, and cardiorespiratory fitness, comparing metabolically healthy (blue bars) versus unhealthy (red bars) individuals within each weight category. It highlights that metabolic health issues increase as weight status progresses from normal to obese.

Apple Podcasts and Spotify do not show images in the episode description. Try Pocket Casts, or another podcast app.

“Outlive: A Critical Review” by MichaelDickens

LessWrong (30+ Karma)