In this episode of the Overthink podcast, the hosts dive into the complexities of disagreement, examining how online disputes differ from face-to-face arguments. They share a personal experience of a challenging conversation about whether art can be separated from its creator, showcasing the difficulty of having constructive discussions, even among friends. The hosts then take a historical look at how disagreements have been handled, ranging from Socratic dialogues and medieval debates to early modern correspondence, and contrast these with the often chaotic "shitstorms" seen on social media today. They also touch on the epistemological side of disagreement, emphasizing the need to acknowledge expertise and the ethics of keeping discussions respectful, even when opinions clash deeply. The discussion includes the example of Jop and Dop to highlight the difference between disagreements over beliefs and actions.
