This Round Table discussion delves into the backlash against Coca-Cola's AI-generated Christmas commercial. Although the AI successfully mirrored the nostalgic imagery of the long-standing campaign, viewers reacted unfavorably due to the unsettling "uncanny valley" effect and minor visual errors, leading them to feel a lack of human warmth and emotional resonance. The conversation examines whether this discontent arises from the use of AI itself, the execution flaws in the visuals, or a broader unease about AI's influence on creative employment. Conversely, some argue that the ad is still effective, pointing out the enduring power of brand recognition despite the criticism.
