198. The Pirate Trial of the Century

This episode explores the life and controversial legacy of Captain William Kidd, examining whether he was a victim of circumstance or a willful pirate. Against the backdrop of his commission as a privateer, the hosts debate Kidd's actions, with one arguing he was driven to piracy by a series of misfortunes and the pressure of a mutinous crew, culminating in the murder of William Moore. More significantly, the discussion delves into Kidd's attacks on Mughal vessels, a direct challenge to the East India Company's interests, and the subsequent accusations of Jacobite involvement. For instance, a letter from Thomas Pattle detailing Kidd's attacks on Mughal ships is presented as evidence against him. In contrast, the other host argues that Kidd was pushed to extremes by his circumstances, a failed commission, and the betrayal of his backers, ultimately leading to his downfall. The episode concludes with Kidd's trial, conviction, and execution, highlighting the conflicting narratives surrounding his life and the enduring mystery of his buried treasure, with the recent discovery of the Kedah Merchant wreck adding another layer to the complex story.