This podcast episode explores a tragic fire in Pittsburgh in 1995 that resulted in the deaths of three firefighters. The investigation reveals that the fire was intentionally set, leading to the arrest and trial of Greg Brown Jr. and Darlene for arson, insurance fraud, conspiracy, and triple homicide. The defense highlights flaws in the investigation, including a lack of scientific methodology and a questionable motive. Despite maintaining their innocence, Greg and Darlene are faced with the dilemma of considering a plea deal to avoid the risks of another trial. The episode delves into the concept of the Alford plea, where defendants can plead guilty while asserting their innocence. It explores the increasing prevalence of Alford pleas in the criminal justice system and the coercive nature of these pleas. The impact of Greg's decision to accept a plea deal and the lasting burden he carries are also discussed.
